I’m writing this on the Monday after an (apparently) successful trade deal was (apparently) thwarted by last minute additions from the United States that were not acceptable to Canada. These included changes to French language requirements, oversight on trade deals with other countries, changes to supply management, and rules about AI and big tech — many of which seemed to be aimed at decreasing Canada’s sovereignty. I have a couple of thoughts on how the tariffs function and how Trump’s motives are relevant to politics in BC.
The US wants a colony – BC already is one
The major tariffs are almost all on manufactured goods: steel, aluminum, autos, and lumber. Trump has been public about using tariffs to reshore manufacturing from overseas to the United States since imposing them on China during his first term (a failed initiative).
Destroying Canadian manufacturing capacity would relegate us to the status of a colony providing raw materials to the metropole in exchange for the manufactured goods produced there. Canada has been historically sensitive to this possibility. John A. MacDonald’s National Policy put tariff walls around Canada early in confederation to build national manufacturing, for instance. After balancing multiple trade agreements over the 20th century, including the auto pact, which integrated the Canadian and American economies, we now face a US administration that wants to both strip those legacy industries from Canada (steel, aluminum, autos) and control how the new economy (AI and big technology) is regulated.
This is precisely what the British East India Company forced onto India — it dismantled a thriving local cloth manufacturing economy and created a supplier of raw materials for the British cloth mills. I mention this history because for those of us living and working in the hinterland, or in “regional centres” (I live and work in Lheidli T’enneh territory / Prince George BC), this relationship is very familiar. As Markey, Halseth, and Manson argued over a decade ago, “Control of industries and state-delivered services [in Northern BC] is external (multinational capital and metropolitan core regions respectively).”[1] In the early 21st century, Northern British Columbians ostensibly have control over their lands and resources through representation in Victoria. However, the metropole maintains a classically colonial system of control that leads to massive degradation of the Northern BC landscape and resource royalties controlled by governments well beyond us, elected by the more populous regions south of here.
Of course the entirety of BC is already a settler colony – the colonialism of centre-periphery dynamics within the Province only adds to dispossession experienced by First Nations for over 150 years. I think it would be useful for the settler majority in BC to consider on these dynamics when we reflexively bristle at the US attempting to manipulate our economic and political reality.
[1] Sean Markey, Greg Halseth, and Don Manson, Investing in Place: Economic Renewal in Northern British Columbia, Vancouver: UBC Press.